On October 7, 2026, the Town of Herndon filed a notice of appeal with the Court of Appeals of Virginia. It is challenging a Fairfax County Circuit Court order that left the nearly five-acre redevelopment site at Elden and Center streets under Comstock's control. For anyone weighing a home near Old Town, the downtown project's next milestone is now an appellate ruling, and the court's own guidance puts that about a year out with no firm deadline.
For a buyer comparing Herndon with nearby towns, the result is simple to state. The apartments, arts center and public garage once planned for the heart of downtown have no build schedule. The first large wave of new homes and street-level retail in town is going up a mile north, beside the Herndon Metro station, and it will open first.
What the September Ruling Decided
The project that is now stuck was substantial. According to FFXnow's July 2025 reporting, the plan called for 273 apartments, a 4,265-square-foot arts center and plaza, and a 761-space parking garage. The arts center had been proposed at 18,000 square feet in 2017 and was cut down over the years. The town had transferred the land to Comstock in 2020 under an agreement first signed in 2017. Comstock told the town in December 2024 that it would not proceed.
The town's position in its lawsuit was that the land should come back. In the complaint, as FFXnow reported, Herndon described the developer's reading of the contract this way:
"Comstock can issue a Notice Not to Proceed, avoid the consequences of a default, and keep the property in perpetuity, undeveloped, at its own discretion while demanding to be protected from economic risk that it expressly assumed. In other words, 'heads I win, tails you lose.'"
The court disagreed with the town. In an opinion dated September 17, 2026, Judge Tania M.L. Saylor wrote that the town "is not entitled to a reconveyance of the property," according to FFXnow's coverage of the ruling. Two documents settled it. A 2020 amendment to the agreement gave the developer the right to withdraw without penalty if it did so by a certain date. The special warranty deed, in the judge's words, "does not state, directly or indirectly by inference, that Herndon retains a post-conveyance right of reentry to the Property."
The 2017 agreement included the town's right to take the land back, but the 2020 amendment added a penalty-free exit for the developer, and the deed that conveyed the parcel preserved no reentry right for Herndon. Under the circuit court's reading, that combination puts the cost of a stalled project on the town, which is why the ruling's effect goes well beyond one lot.
The Appeal Clock, Counted Forward
Each side has said what it wants next. Mayor Keven LeBlanc said the town "is stunned and disappointed by the court's ruling regarding our land in the heart of our community" and that an appeal was being prepared. In a September 28, 2026 statement on Business Wire, Comstock said it remains "willing to keep with our original intent to work with officials on redeveloping a key piece of Herndon's historic downtown into a Class-A mixed-use development." Neither statement includes a construction plan, a revised design or a date.
The court sets the pace from here. The Court of Appeals of Virginia's published FAQ says that after a notice of appeal is filed, "it usually takes twelve months for all briefs to be filed and for the full review process to take place," and that "there is no time limit for Court of Appeals judges to issue a decision." Counting from October 7, 2026, the typical review window runs to about October 2027. Even a decision on that schedule would only settle who controls the land. Design, approvals and construction would all still have to follow.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| December 2024 | Comstock notifies the town it will not build |
| February 28, 2025 | Town records a declaration terminating Comstock's interest |
| July 11, 2025 | Town sues in Fairfax County Circuit Court for return of the parcel |
| February 27, 2026 | Hearing on both sides' motions for summary judgment |
| September 17, 2026 | Circuit court opinion favors Comstock |
| October 7, 2026 | Town files notice of appeal |
| About October 2027 | End of the court's typical twelve-month review window, with no required decision date |
As of FFXnow's July 2025 description, the site was mostly surface parking plus one commercial building at 750 Center Street, which Arts Herndon had vacated at the end of that March.
Where Herndon's New Homes Are Arriving Instead
While Elden Street waits, the north side of the Herndon Metro station is under construction. FFXnow reported in May 2026 that Fairfield Residential's Nell at 555 will deliver 399 homes, about 5,000 square feet of retail, private amenity space and a parking garage on a 4.3-acre site at 555 Herndon Parkway that once held an office building. Fairfield expects the first residents to move in during early 2027 and construction to finish in late spring 2027. It is the first project approved in the Herndon Transit-Oriented Core under the town's 2012 plan for the 38-acre area.
| Downtown parcel at Elden and Center | Nell at 555, Herndon Parkway | |
|---|---|---|
| Planned homes | 273 apartments | 399 apartments |
| Site size | Nearly 5 acres | 4.3 acres |
| Street-level space | Retail, plus a 4,265-sq-ft arts center | About 5,000 sq ft of retail or restaurant space |
| Status | Under appeal, with no construction schedule | Under construction |
| Earliest date on record | Typical appeal review runs to about October 2027 | First move-ins early 2027 |
The two sites are close in size and planned scale. What separates them is that one has a contractor and a delivery date, and the other has a pending appeal. For the next several years, the dining, foot traffic and new neighbors that come with a few hundred new households will show up first on the Metro side of town.
Regional Pricing and Inventory
In its September 2026 report, published October 16, the Northern Virginia Association of Realtors said the regional median sold price was $744,950, up 4.2% from September 2025. Closed sales fell 7.5% to 1,250, and average days on market held at 28. Active listings rose 30.7% year over year. Condo and townhome inventory grew 49.7%, while detached-home inventory rose 5.7%. Months of supply reached 2.5, still below the five to six months NVAR associates with a balanced market. These are figures for all of Northern Virginia, not for Herndon alone.
The November 3 Ballot
The next decision point arrives before any court ruling. Herndon's town election is Tuesday, November 3, 2026, five days after this post publishes, and the Virginia Department of Elections candidate list shows Mayor LeBlanc on the ballot. Twelve candidates are running for six Town Council seats. According to FFXnow, six of them signed a letter pledging to keep working to recover the property and to include enforceable deadlines and protections for the town in any future developer agreement.
The next council will decide whether to pursue the appeal to the end, negotiate with Comstock, or do some of both. Comstock has said publicly that it prefers a negotiated route. The pledge to include enforceable deadlines responds directly to the gap the circuit court found between the 2020 amendment and the deed.
One practical note for anyone with town business before year-end: the Herndon Municipal Center is closed for renovation from October 2, 2026 through January 2, 2027, and town services have moved to 397 Herndon Parkway.
Questions Buyers Raise About the Downtown Site
Who controls the parcel right now? Comstock Herndon Venture, LC. The town's own update says the September ruling allows the developer "to retain control of the property for the time being" while the appeal is pending.
Is the arts center still part of any plan? No current plan exists. The 4,265-square-foot arts center belonged to the project Comstock withdrew from in December 2024, and no replacement design has been announced by either side.
Could the two sides settle before the appeal is decided? Comstock's September 28 statement calls for a "collaborative approach" instead of continued litigation, and the town has said it is pursuing "all available legal avenues and strategic options." Both statements leave room for talks, and no agreement has been announced.
This post reports on public court filings and contract terms as covered in the sources linked above. It is general information, not legal or financial advice, and readers should confirm their own situation with the appropriate professional.
At Dianne Van Volkenburg, we follow land-use cases like this one closely because they decide what gets built next to a home, and when. If you are weighing a home near Old Town or along Herndon Parkway and want to understand how the downtown appeal and the Metro-area construction affect a specific address, request a private consultation.